Black Workers and the Public Sector
The standoff in Wisconsin highlights the fiscal crisis facing state and local governments across the country. Required by law to balance their budgets, politicians in state legislatures, school boards, and city councils are faced with the choices of cutting public services and laying off workers, raising revenue, or some combination of the two. They are deciding these choices in an economic context where the Great Recession caused the deficits and any deficit – reduction option exerts a drag on the recovery.i
Since January 2009, state and local governments have laid off 429,000 workers. ii As governments contemplate additional layoffs, it is important to note that few commentators have examined the racial implications of this reduction in government employment. This is an important question to address because often policy prescriptions that, on the surface, are race – neutral can have decidedly racial impacts. T his research brief explores the issue by analyzing the nature of Black employment in the public sector. In July 2010, the Center for Labor Research and Education released a report examining the state of Black workers in the years 2005 – 07, before the onset of the Great Recession. This report partially updates that report by examining how Black workers have fared during the past three years of recession and recovery. The sections below examine the importance of the public sector to Black employment prospects in both time periods and how the wage inequality that Black workers face differs between public and private sectors.
The results of this study are striking:
- The public sector is the single most important source of employment for African Americans.
- During 2008 – 2010, 21.2% of all Black workers are public employees, compared with 16.3% of non – Black workers. Both before and after the onset of the Great Recession, African Americans were 30% more likely than other workers to be employed in the public sector.
- Th e public sector is also a critical source of decent – paying jobs for Black Americans. For both men and women, the median wage earned by Black employees is significantly higher in the public sector than in other industries.
- Prior to the recession, the wage differential between Black and white workers was less in the public sector than in the overall economy
- Examining the five primary industries employing Black workers, the public sector employed the greatest proportion of Black men and Black women in the hi gher paying occupations
- In these same industries, the public sector employed the lowest proportion of Black women in lower paying occupations.
Changes in the Importance of the Public Sector to Black Employment Prospects Between 2005 – 2007 and 2008 – 2010 iii
Of the thirteen major industry sectors, Public Administration was the leading employer of Black iv workers both before (2005 – 2007) and after the onset of the Great Recession (2008 – 2010). (When the Bureau of Labor Statistics reports data for the thirteen maj or industry sector, some workers who are employed by governmental authorities are included in categories other than Public Administration (i.e. public school teachers are included in the category Educational and Health Services). In this report, the categ ory Public Administration includes all workers originally in that major industry sector and all workers in the other twelve sectors who employed by governmental authorities. The terms public administration and public sector will be used interchangeably in this report.) In both time periods, the public sector was the leading employer of Black men and the second leading employer of Black women. Table 1 presents data on the proportion of Black workers in the public sector.
The public sector is also the leading employer of non – Black workers in both time periods; however, the proportion of non – Black workers in the public sector is significantly lower. (The public sector is the third leading employer of non – Black men in both time periods and the second leading employer of non – Black women in both time periods.) Table 2 presents this data.
Another way to consider the importance of public sector employment for African Americans is to compare the likelihood that a Black worker is employed in the public sector to the likelihood that a non – Black worker is employed in the public sector. For example, prior to the Great Recession, 20.9% of Black workers were employed in the public sector compared to 15.7% of non – Black workers; consequently, a Black worker was 33% more likely to be employed in the public sector compared to a non – Black worker (20.9/15.7 = 1.33). Table 3 presents these likelihoods.
The Importance of the Public Sector to Black Employment Prospects: 2005 – 2007
During the three years prior to the Great Recession (2005 – 2007), five of the thirteen major industry sectors employed 70.6% of all Black workers: Public Administration, Education and Health Services, Wholesale and Retail Trade, Manufacturing, and Professional and Business Services. Table 4 presents data on the proportion of Black workers that were employed in these sectors.
Public Administration employed 20.9 % of all Black workers and led all industries. It was also the leading employer of Black men (18.0%) and the second leading employer of Black women (23.3%) . Table 5 presents corresponding data for white workers.
While Public Administration was the largest employer of white workers, the proportion of white workers in the public sector (16.9%) was less than the proportion of Black workers in the public sector. In addition, while the public sector wa s the leading employer of white women, it wa s only the third leading employer of white men. For women and men, the share of whit e workers in the public sector was less that the share of Black workers in the public sector. v
The Importance of the Public Sector in Providing Good Jobs for the Black Community
These facts demonstrate the importance of the public sector in providing jobs for the Black community. In addition to the provision of jobs, employment in the public sector paid more than jobs typically held by private sector Black workers. vi Tables 6 and 7 present data on the median wages earned by Black workers.
Median wages for Black workers in the public sector were $17.00 (men) and $15.50 (women). These figures we re higher than the four other leading industries and the workforce – wide median. Black men in the public sector earn ed 23.6% more than Black men in the entire workforce; Black women in the public sector earn ed 25.4% more than Black women in the entire workforce.
The Importance of the Public Sector for Reducing Wage Inequality
The public sector wa s also important in reducing the level of wage inequality in employment. This can be seen in two dimensions. The first dimension of wage inequality reflects racial inequality. The Black – white wage disparity is less in the public sector compared to the entire workforce. Black male and female workers in the public sector earn ed 80.0% and 89.1% of white workers in the public sector, respectively. In all industries , the comparable percentages were 74.3% and 85.4%. The lower racial wage disparity was true for Black men and women in all of the four other leading industries except for Black women in Wholesale and Retail Trade. Table 8 presents these data.
A second dimension of wage inequality reflects distribution of workers within industries. There wa s less compression of Black workers into the lowest paying jobs of the public sector compared to the other leading industries. One approach to measure this distribution is to stratify the industry by wages, divide the entire workforce into terciles (each containing 33.3% of the workforce), and observe the distribution of Black workers among each of the terciles. If parity exists, then one – third (33.3%) of all Black workers in the industry would be in each tercile. Table 9 presents these data. Compared to the other leading industries, the public sector had the lowest proportion of Black women in the least paid tercile a proportion of Black women in the highest paid tercile. The public sector was on par with Educational and Health Services and Wholesale and Retail Trade in terms of the proportion of Black men in the least paid tercile and on par with Wholesale and Retail Trade in the terms of the proportion of Black men in the highest paid tercile.
This research brief documents that the public sector plays a unique role in the labor market outcomes for the Black community. The public sector is the largest employer of Black workers; there is a greater likelihood that a Black worker will be employed in the public sector compared to a non – Black worker; wages earned by Blacks in that industry are higher than those earned by Blacks in other sectors; and inequality within an industry is less in the public sector compared to other industries. It is important to note that this data reflects the national workforce; it is a plausible assumption that in many cities where Blacks are a larger proportion of the general population and a larger proportion of the workforce, the importance of the public sector to Black employment prospects will rise. Consequently, any analysis of the impact to society of additional layoffs in the public sector as a strategy to address the fiscal crisis should take into account the disproportionate impact that reductions in government employment have on the Black community.
- Cutting services and/or laying off workers reduce the spending in the economy as the government spending falls or laid – off workers spend less; tax increases reduce the spending power of consumers as after – tax income falls. In either case, overall demand for goods and services fall which, in turns, slows the pace of the economic recovery.
- The numbers in this brief was calculated using data from the Current Population Survey. In order to generate a reliable sample, data were pooled together from the years 2005 – 2007 and 2008 – 2010.
- In this analysis, “Blacks” are defined as non – Latino Blacks and “whites” are defined as non – Latino whites. Non – Latino Blacks, non – Latino whites, and Latinos are mutually exclusive categories.
- It is important to note that the fact that Blacks in the public sector earn more than Blacks who are not employed in the public sector does not imply that Black government workers are overpaid. Two distinct questions are involved: 1) are Black workers in the public sector paid more than their skill – equivalent in the private sector; and 2) do Black workers in the public sector represent a strata in the Black community that earn more than what is typical in the Black community
‘What the hell do you have to lose?’ A lot, actually
San Francisco Chronicle | September 21, 2018
How Automation Could Worsen Racial Inequality
The Atlantic | January 16, 2018
Blacks get screwed under Trump’s proposed budget, but what else is new?
Daily Kos | March 16, 2017
Federal shutdowns still loom by year’s end
Philadelphia Tribune | October 3, 2015
How public sector layoffs add to the racial income gap
MSNBC | March 19, 2014
Illinois Pension Debate Overlooks Role of Public-Sector Jobs in Sustaining the Middle Class
Chicago Now | November 7, 2013
The Real Invisible Obama Shows Up on Race and the Economy
Colorlines | September 6, 2012
How Do You Talk About Black Unemployment Without Talking About Government Jobs?
Slate | July 11, 2012
Romney’s Chilly Reception at the NAACP
The Nation | July 11, 2012
Obama Was Right. It’s the (Public Sector) Economy, Stupid
Colorlines | July 11, 2012
Here’s Why Black Unemployment Has Gone Through The Roof
Business Insider | September 2, 2011
Conservatives Try (and Fail) to Paint Unions as Bad for Black People
The Nation | May 13, 2011