Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image

Center for Labor Research and Education


Scroll to top


Study: Fewer Workers Insured

Los Angeles Times

The number of Californians lacking health insurance will grow
by about 20% over the next five years as premiums rise and fewer
jobs offer employer-sponsored coverage, predicted a study released
Wednesday by UC Berkeley researchers.

Low- and middle-income adults in California will be most dramatically
affected if current trends continue, concluded the study, conducted
by the UC Berkeley Center for Labor Research and Education and the
union-affiliated Working Partnerships USA, a San Jose-based nonprofit

From 2000 to 2004, the percentage of California full-time workers
making $9 to $11 an hour with employer-based coverage dropped from
more than 59% to 46%, the researchers found. Nationwide, the decline
for this pay range was from 64% to 58%.

"What we are facing is a downward spiral in healthcare coverage
— and California is five years further down the path than
the nation as a whole," said Ken Jacobs, co-author and deputy
chairman of the center.

Growth in the number of uninsured patients drives up healthcare
costs, "and that in turn pushes more people into the ranks
of the uninsured" by further discouraging employers from offering
insurance, Jacobs said.

Arindrajit Dube, an economist at the center and a co-author, said
the results were worrisome because the kinds of jobs being added
most quickly in California pay about $9 an hour.

"The most alarming thing is that precisely where we are seeing
job growth in California, that is where we are seeing the biggest
declines of employer-sponsored healthcare," Dube said.

From 2000 to 2004, the number of all adults in California with
access to health coverage through an employer declined to 58% from
61%, the study found.

These are just the issues that concern the California Chamber of
Commerce, said spokeswoman Sara Lee. The study highlights the need
to control healthcare costs, she said.

The research, part of a more extensive study expected to be released
in July with more data on health coverage for California’s children,
took more than a year to complete.

It analyzed data from the U.S. Census Bureau, the state Department
of Finance and health surveys to forecast insurance costs given
current trends.

The work is being underwritten by grants from the nonprofit California
Endowment and the Blue Shield Foundation of California.

As premiums for healthcare coverage escalate, more employers argue
that they need to pass on costs to employees or drop coverage altogether
to stay competitive, the study found.

That is happening throughout the nation, said Joanne Spetz, an
economist at UC San Francisco who specializes in healthcare issues.

"This study doesn’t surprise me. As costs go up, employers
get rid of coverage or try to pass on the costs," said Spetz,
who was not involved in the Berkeley study.

Nationwide, the annual cost to employees for job-based family coverage
increased from $6,567 in 2000 to $9,831 in 2004, the study found
— an average annual increase of 11% that far outpaced growth
in wages.

"The pillar on which our healthcare system as a whole relies,
employer-based coverage, is deteriorating," said Anthony Wright,
executive director of Health Access California, an Oakland-based
nonprofit. "We are getting dangerously close to a tipping point
where companies that are providing coverage have no choice but to
drop it."

Losing coverage

In most income categories, the percentage of full-time workers
in California with employer-sponsored health insurance declined
from 2000 to 2004.

Percentage of full-time workers receiving employer-sponsored coverage:

Below $9/hour*

2004: 27.9%
2000: 30.6%

$9 to $11/hour

2004: 45.9%
2000: 59.4%

$11 to $13/hour

2004: 63.5%
2000: 66.2%

$13 to $15/hour

2004: 68.5%
2000: 75.0%

$15 to $19/hour

2004: 77.0%
2000: 76.7%

$19 to $23/hour

2004: 75.5%
2000: 81.5%

$23 or more/hour

2004: 82.7%
2000: 84.9%

*Wage groups are in 2004 dollars.

Sources: Census Bureau’s March Current Population Survey, UC
Berkeley Center for Labor Research and Education